Russia · The best of Pat Buchanan

Is a Trump- Putin Detente dead?

“Is a Trump- Putin Detente dead?”, Pat Buchanan, February 20, 2017:

Among the reasons Donald Trump is president is that he read the nation and the world better than his rivals.

He saw the surging power of American nationalism at home, and of ethnonationalism in Europe. And he embraced Brexit.

While our bipartisan establishment worships diversity, Trump saw Middle America recoiling from the demographic change brought about by Third World invasions. And he promised to curb them.

While our corporatists burn incense at the shrine of the global economy, Trump went to visit the working-class casualties. And those forgotten Americans in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan and Wisconsin, responded.

And while Bush II and President Obama plunged us into Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Yemen, Syria, Trump saw that his countrymen wanted to be rid of the endless wars, and start putting America first.

He offered a new foreign policy. Mitt Romney notwithstanding, said Trump, Putin’s Russia is not “our number one geopolitical foe.”

Moreover, that 67-year-old NATO alliance that commits us to go to war to defend two dozen nations, not one of whom contributes the same share of GDP as do we to national defense, is “obsolete.”

Many of these folks are freeloaders, said Trump. He hopes to work with Russia against our real enemies, al-Qaida and ISIS.

This was the agenda Americans voted for. But what raises doubt about whether Trump can follow through on his commitments is the size and virulence of the anti-Trump forces in this city.

Consider his plan to pursue a rapprochement with Russia such as Ike, JFK at American University, Nixon and Reagan all pursued in a Cold War with a far more menacing Soviet Empire.

America’s elites still praise FDR for partnering with one of the great mass murderers of human history, Stalin, to defeat Hitler. They still applaud Nixon for going to China to achieve a rapprochement with the greatest mass murderer of the 20th century, Mao Zedong.

Yet Trump is not to be allowed to achieve a partnership with Putin, whose great crime was a bloodless retrieval of a Crimea that had belonged to Russia since the 18th century.

The anti-Putin paranoia here is astonishing.

That he is a killer, a KGB thug, a murderer, is part of the daily rant of John McCain. At the Munich Security Conference this last weekend, Sen. Lindsey Graham promised, “2017 is going to be a year of kicking Russia in the ass in Congress.” How’s that for statesmanship.

But how does a president negotiate a modus vivendi with a rival great power when the leaders of his own party are sabotaging him and his efforts?

As for the mainstream media, they appear bent upon the ruin of Trump, and the stick with which they mean to beat him to death is this narrative:

Trump is the Siberian Candidate, the creature of Putin and the Kremlin. His ties to the Russians are old and deep. It was to help Trump that Russia hacked the DNC and the computer of Clinton campaign chief John Podesta, and saw to it WikiLeaks got the emails out to the American people during the campaign. Trump’s people secretly collaborated with Russian agents.

Believing Putin robbed Hillary Clinton of the presidency, Democrats are bent on revenge — on Putin and Trump.

And the epidemic of Russophobia makes it almost impossible to pursue normal relations. Indeed, in reaction to the constant attacks on them as poodles of Putin, the White House seems to be toughening up toward Russia.

Thus we see U.S. troops headed for Poland, Bulgaria, Romania, NATO troops being sent into the Baltic States, and new tough rhetoric from the White House about Russia having to restore Crimea to Ukraine. We read of Russian spy ships off the coast, Russian planes buzzing U.S. warships in the Black Sea, Russians deploying missiles outlawed by the arms control agreement of 1987.

An Ohio-class U.S. sub just test-fired four Trident missiles, which carry thermonuclear warheads, off the Pacific coast.

Any hope of cutting a deal for a truce in east Ukraine, a lifting of sanctions, and bringing Russia back into Europe seems to be fading.

Where Russians saw hope with Trump’s election, they are now apparently yielding to disillusionment and despair.

The question arises: If not toward better relations with Russia, where are we going with this bellicosity?

Russia is not going to give up Crimea. Not only would Putin not do it, the Russian people would abandon him if he did.

What then is the end goal of this bristling Beltway hostility to Putin and Russia, and the U.S.-NATO buildup in the Baltic and Black Sea regions? Is a Cold War II with Russia now an accepted and acceptable reality?

Where are the voices among Trump’s advisers who will tell him to hold firm against the Russophobic tide and work out a deal with the Russian president?

For a second cold war with Russia, its back up against a wall, may not end quite so happily as the first.

3 thoughts on “Is a Trump- Putin Detente dead?

  1. I have a few questions I’d love to hear your thoughts on…

    1. Do you think NATO is defunct even though it has kept peace in the West for many, many years?
    2. Do you think Russia is a better ally for America than Europe?
    3. What do you think about the US government’s intelligence agencies concluding that the Russian government interfered in the 2016 United States elections, should Americans not care about this?
    4. Do you think Trump potentially being on track to spend more tax dollars on travel/ expenses etc than Obama did in 8 years, filling his office with billionaires, using every opportunity he has to publicise his and his family’s businesses (Ivanka Trump’s clothes line, Mar-a-Largo, Trump hotels) is his way of aligning himself with the America’s ‘working class casualties’?
    5. Do you think it’s possible Trump and some in his office (Rex Tillerson and others) might have something to gain from lifting sanctions on Russia?

    These are just some of the questions, among many other disconcerting actions, like not permitting entry to certain news outlets for a state-funded press conference, that sit uncomfortably with many so it would be interesting to hear your take on them.

  2. One wonders, if Brexit had not happened would the people who voted for Donald Trump come out in such force. Brexit was the encouragement perhaps. Then surely the courage of those people who voted for Brexit should be applauded not ridiculed., Brexit does not mean racists which is the cry here and elsewhere. I voted Brexit as I waited over 40 years to see us out of Europe, I did not vote Brexit because I am a racist as has been the chant here for anyone who voted for Brexit. I voted Brexit because I was sick to death of seeing the wastage of money that we were pouring into Europe over the years, even bailing out Countries like Ireland, they had their Celtic Tiger and wasted it they demanded help and got it, my parents were immigrants from Ireland and I love Ireland, whilst poor Greece was blamed for everything. I voted Brexit, because I wanted this Country to make its own Laws once more not have to abide by stupid EU Laws like “straight bananas and cucumbers” ridiculous. I want us to control our own borders, Angela Merkel told all the immigrants/migrants “welcome all come” and then expected people like the UK to handle the situation, well we can’t. Does that make us Racists. The good decent hard working people of America who have not had a fair deal for far too long, saw what we did here voting Brexit and believed that they could do the same and they did. Trump did what no other Politician did and he is not a Politician, he listened he saw, thats why you have President Trump. If he embraces Brexit, than I am very proud that he does. As for Russia, are you forgetting who the real enemy is it is not Russia it is the Terrorists it is those in the Middle East who are backing these Terrorists. The Terrorists live amongst us, we should do well to remember that.

    1. Hm I think that’s an interesting one. The populist momentum from Brexit certainly added enthusiasm to Trump’s cause. So perhaps without Brexit Trump wouldn’t have won. But one thing I can tell you with certainty, is that I cheered on both events and they were great days for the world to see!

Leave a Reply